+- Haley Reinhart Forum (http://haleyfans.com)
+-- Forum: Topics (http://haleyfans.com/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Other Idols & Other Shows (http://haleyfans.com/forum-18.html)
+--- Thread: Elise Testone (/thread-1652.html)
Pages:
1
2
RE: Elise Testone - mercfan3 - 03-18-2013
Honestly, for me..it's simply the emotion when she sings. I can talk about how sound Haley is, on a technical level, until I am blue in the face. But the truth is, when she sings...I feel something. Her voice warms the heart and gives chills at the same time.
I just didn't feel that way with Elise.
RE: Elise Testone - 30CamdenSquare - 03-18-2013
Thanks for posting those vids Tusk!! I like Elise. I like her alot. She was my favorite from S11. I like Haley more & I don't think Elise & Haley sound much alike other than they both have some rasp in their tone. They both have good tastes in music (which means they like a lot of the same music that I like), but they don't have the same style even when singing the same songs. There's quite a bit of difference in their phrasing/note choices and Elise CANNOT belt like Haley, but she still sounds great and sings a lot of music that I like. I especially liked that first video that Tusk just posted. The melody in the chorus is really cool.
RE: Elise Testone - My Alter Ego - 03-19-2013
(03-18-2013, 11:31 PM)30CamdenSquare Wrote: Thanks for posting those vids Tusk!! I like Elise. I like her alot. She was my favorite from S11. I like Haley more & I don't think Elise & Haley sound much alike other than they both have some rasp in their tone. They both have good tastes in music (which means they like a lot of the same music that I like), but they don't have the same style even when singing the same songs. There's quite a bit of difference in their phrasing/note choices and Elise CANNOT belt like Haley, but she still sounds great and sings a lot of music that I like. I especially liked that first video that Tusk just posted. The melody in the chorus is really cool.
30CS, that's a very good analysis (of the differences between Haley and Elise).
And to try to clarify my earlier post, I have a great deal of respect for Elise's musicianship. I may not like what she does and I may not listen to complete songs, but I respect what she does, because she definitely knows what and how she wants to deliver a song.
RE: Elise Testone - lovinghaleyr - 03-19-2013
(03-18-2013, 10:14 PM)mercfan3 Wrote: Honestly, for me..it's simply the emotion when she sings. I can talk about how sound Haley is, on a technical level, until I am blue in the face. But the truth is, when she sings...I feel something. Her voice warms the heart and gives chills at the same time.
I just didn't feel that way with Elise.
MF3:agree with you because I feel exactly the same things when Haley sing (don't matter what) her voice hold my soul,my heart and give me chills up and down for my spin
