RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - Miguel - 10-12-2015
Most recent YT comment on one of the unofficial videos:
Quote:this video is amazing. it brings back memories of me & my wife. we met in college, got married a year after and 19 years later, she passed away. 6 months ago. Damn. this hurts a lot & Yes, love matters. I missed her & falling in love with her again. thanks for sharing this video.
tweet:
Quote:my life is over because of a gum commercial I saw it before but without sound and the song shattered me tbh
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - Tusk - 10-12-2015
Hmm... aparently it's been on TV..
Quote:Vanessa Salles @vsalles_ 4h4 hours ago (New Jersey)
.@HaleyReinhart's version of #CantHelpFallingInLove is all I've ever needed in life. So, so good
Quote:Hayli Wells @hayliwellss 1h1 hour ago
@vsalles_ @HaleyReinhart was it on Grey's the other night?? I heard it on something and now can't remember
Quote:Hayli Wells @hayliwellss 1h1 hour ago
@vsalles_ @HaleyReinhart wait it was an Extra gum commercial
Quote:Vanessa Salles @vsalles_ 1h1 hour ago
@hayliwellss @HaleyReinhart yup, the commercial!!!!!
Quote:Hayli Wells @hayliwellss 1h1 hour ago
@vsalles_ @HaleyReinhart I cried
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - john - 10-12-2015
Quote:Olivia Goldsmith 6 minutes ago
What brought me here is to figure out why no one has mentioned the direct rip off of Ingrid Michelson. This is the exact arrangement of falling in love done by Ingrid i have been listening to it for years. The fact that she is not the one singing in the commercial is appalling.
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - Tusk - 10-12-2015
Quote:Janelle @IhartZeReinhart 3h3 hours ago
My teacher showed the gum commercial in class today cause shes in love with it and so many people asked who was singing omf
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - Miguel - 10-12-2015
Comment on YT:
Quote:We watched this commercial today in our English class and honestly at first I thought it would be some lame commercial, but after a bit I started seeing the message and I couldn't even hold back I just started to bawl so badly
I can hear the similarities to Ingrid Michelson's arrangement. When I gave her version a brief listen the other day, I didn't notice them. Probably because it was a very brief listen.
Though I think Haley is the perfect choice for the ad, I can understand a fan of Ingrid's being upset she wasn't given the opportunity, or credit. Consider how we felt about The Voice and "Creep."
Edit, found this:
"Arrangements are what the Copyright Act calls derivative works. Making derivative works is a right exclusively granted to the songwriter under copyright law. The arranger can claim a copyright only when the songwriter has granted that privilege to the arranger.
...Not only can Sarah (used in their example) not stop the Bobbletones from using her arrangements, she also cannot stop each and every a cappella group in the country from making their own Michael Jackson Tribute CDs using her arrangements."
http://www.acappella101.com/home/who-owns-the-arrangement
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - Tusk - 10-12-2015
Where I hear the most similarity is in the Piano. Though she sings the 'same' notes, IMO the execution isn't the same. She sings in a 'stop and go', stilted way (don't have the musical verbiage to explain ) Where as Haley's performance she sings notes that glide into each other.
The words I use to describe Haley's cover is that she 'vocally carresses' the lyrics... she's a ballerina to Ingrid's tapdancer, how they get from one phrase to the other IMO, a grace.
Using the Creep example, the same thing. Haley's has a smooth swing and grace and transition to it, while IMO Karen's cover has a completely different attitude, stop and go, abrupt.
(again apologies for not understanding music to the extent that i can describe what I'm hearing)
It's like the difference between wearing cotton and silk. Cotton does the job but Silk feels just a little better on your skin
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - midnightblues - 10-12-2015
(10-12-2015, 08:27 PM)Miguel Wrote: Most recent YT comment on one of the unofficial videos:
Quote:this video is amazing. it brings back memories of me & my wife. we met in college, got married a year after and 19 years later, she passed away. 6 months ago. Damn. this hurts a lot & Yes, love matters. I missed her & falling in love with her again. thanks for sharing this video.
tweet:
Quote:my life is over because of a gum commercial I saw it before but without sound and the song shattered me tbh
so sorry to here about your wife
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - Miguel - 10-12-2015
(10-12-2015, 10:40 PM)midnightblues Wrote: so sorry to here about your wife
Hey midnight, good to see you around. To be clear, I was quoting someone. I've never been married.
(10-12-2015, 10:31 PM)Tusk Wrote: she's a ballerina to Ingrid's tapdancer
That's an interesting way to phrase it.
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - midnightblues - 10-12-2015
(10-12-2015, 10:46 PM)Miguel Wrote: Hey midnight, good to see you around. To be clear, I was quoting someone. I've never been married
oops but married or not it hurts real bad to lose someone. If you find someone to love, hold on tooth and nail
RE: Haley Reinhart for Extra Gum: "Can't Help Falling in Love" - Tusk - 10-12-2015
Wasn't there a way to see how many ads were run?
Since the conversation about hearing the gum ad during Grey's Anatomy, I've had ABC on and nothing...
As popular as the commercial's been, you would think on a popular show such as Grey's, more than 2 people wouldve heard it?
Are these tweets of it being on tv genuine? It seems more than 2 nationwide would have heard it?
|