"CREEP" - PMJ studio version with HALEY

[popfly38]

Next YT milestone is Homeless Mustard's Creep cover posted 6 years ago. It is proclaimed as 'THE GREATEST COVER EVER..' . With 21,508,155 views, I guess that is about to be challenged. I hope he's not still homeless because I think he's going down in about a 3 weeks.

[dswim2]

She's also going to pass up Scotty! So she'll have the most viewed YT video from a season 10 contestant. Scotty's video: 21,407,565

[john]

Next YT milestone is Homeless Mustard's Creep cover posted 6 years ago. It is proclaimed the as 'THE GREATEST COVER EVER..' . With 21,508,155 views, I guess that is about to be challenged. I hope he's not still homeless because I think he's going down in about a 3 weeks.

LOL. I recently saw that was coming into sight. There are lots of really good covers of Creep on YT. For singers who have the pipes it seems to be a great choice in singing competitions. Jena Irene on AI, Kimberly Nichole on The Voice and most recently, Brian Justin on AGT all received kudos for their renditions.

But Haley sets the standard, reaching that magic level for lots of people and leaving those others in the dust. It has been a game changer for Haley. The only other cover of Creep that I occasionally listen to is the Pretenders' version, which is more like the original.

FB

Well this is pretty fucking great.

[Miguel]

"Creep" is making a bit of a resurgence on FB. It's always popular, but the Lost Pinup version seems to have caught a second wind today.

Then there is this guy in Virginia Beach:

Bill H.
YouTube
·
I woke up from my nap today (Yeah, nap. There's not much else to do with a broken foot and painkillers.} What woke me up was a very strange dream. In the dream, my knee scooter was a motorcycle and I was riding all over the place. I found this weird bar on the waterfront called Rhinehart's. It looked like a ship from the outside. I ran into some old friends there but before we could go in, my cell phone rang. That's when I woke up.

Here in VB, we do have a restaurant that looks like a ship on the outside. It's called Captain George's. So when I woke up, I Googled "Rhinehart's'' and found a similar place in Augusta, Georgia. I've never been to Augusta, Georgia. Then I changed the spelling to "Reinharts" and got this young lady. I don't know what to think about all this. The mind is a terrible thing.

[john]

FB exchange. First guy posted Creep with comment and some of the replies (+) and replies to replies (++) follow. On his FB page the poster describes himself as "Vocalist, songwriter, producer, musical theater composer, author, arranger, photographer!"

Jon Montgomery shared Scott Bradlee's video. 2 hrs ·
Hailee Rheinhart is just the best singer in the world right now!

+Ray Melnik I saw her with them last December and she was amazing.

++Jon Montgomery Yeah brother, she has it all. Range, Power, Subtlety, that catch in her voice, passion, vibrato, and she is gorgeous!

++Ray Melnik She did this live at the St George theater in my town and blew everyone away.

++Jon Montgomery To think, she did not win that idiot American Idol trash!

++Ray Melnik I did not know that. Boy did they miss the mark.

.
+Suzanne Ross Great song; love her voice and her stylings.

++Jon Montgomery Yeah, she and Post Modern Jukebox are bringing back some sweet jazz. And it's so cool!

.

[john]

FB

Brian M, quite possibly the most perfect cover of all time

Man oh man, can that girl sing!! Literally gives me chills. Wow.

... wow! amazing vocal control, whether in her lyric head voice or her belting chest voice! and the arrangement is gorgeous, too!

[NUG]

A new review of Creep - by two who previously reviewed Oops!



WHAT?? at the guy questioning something studio related (implying auto tune?) at the end

[john]

WHAT?? at the guy questioning something studio related (implying auto tune?) at the end

Bait. They did Haley no favors.

They put her up against Sarah Geronimo who is a major celebrity in the Philipines and planted the autotune seed. Thanks.

The Sarah Geronimo reaction video on the NGN channel has 49,119 views, with 2,707 Likes and 17 dislikes. The reaction video of Haley's PMJ version has 16,752 views, with 296 likes and (cough) 230 dislikes. Here is Sarah Geronimo (the video they are watching has 52K views in two years).



Comments on the reaction video to Haley's version:

bryan buscado 5 days ago
Lol, this battle is between Live Vs Computerized. Haha obvious answer

John Michael Tacliad5 days ago
i would choose sarrah over haley not because im a filipino.but because sarrah's performance is live and this one is a music video and i think there are already fixings happen on audio and voice

[reply]
+Janno Regala 15 hours ago
yah it was recorded live off course , but definetly they already fix something on that video


I guess that ultimately such comments are complements

Ozzy Carpio 2 days ago
hailey's version is very american idol and sarah g. version is like theatrical,... Vocally Hailey.. Performance.. Sarah.. wahhh.. Love Them... Arrr

migs valler5 days ago
Well i more preferred sarah geronimo's version. You can really feel the meaning of the song with her performance, taking me somewhere like what a person's feel when others mock you down , and sarah's version was LIVE yes LIVE while hailey's like a music video and theres a lot of fixing happens with the audio. Just saying. But thanks for making this VS thingy

Michael Angelo Depusoy
That's not live. That's recorded and edited

JK Velarde 5 days ago
Asia's Popstar Queen
SARAH GERONIMO

(his pick)

Romeo Estrella4 days ago
watched sarah's version of creep in the first night of her concert...That's way better than the video you reacted....I Love sarah and thank you for making reaction videos of Filipino singers....Thank you and more power to you...^_^

Worth ignoring

[ChiTownHalien]

WHAT?? at the guy questioning something studio related (implying auto tune?) at the end

Bait. They did Haley no favors.

They put her up against Sarah Geronimo who is a major celebrity in the Philipines and planted the autotune seed. Thanks.

The Sarah Geronimo reaction video on the NGN channel has 49,119 views, with 2,707 Likes and 17 dislikes. The reaction video of Haley's PMJ version has 16,752 views, with 296 likes and (cough) 230 dislikes. Here is Sarah Geronimo (the video they are watching has 52K views in two years).



Comments on the reaction video to Haley's version:

bryan buscado 5 days ago
Lol, this battle is between Live Vs Computerized. Haha obvious answer

John Michael Tacliad5 days ago
i would choose sarrah over haley not because im a filipino.but because sarrah's performance is live and this one is a music video and i think there are already fixings happen on audio and voice

[reply]
+Janno Regala 15 hours ago
yah it was recorded live off course , but definetly they already fix something on that video


I guess that ultimately such comments are complements

Ozzy Carpio 2 days ago
hailey's version is very american idol and sarah g. version is like theatrical,... Vocally Hailey.. Performance.. Sarah.. wahhh.. Love Them... Arrr

migs valler5 days ago
Well i more preferred sarah geronimo's version. You can really feel the meaning of the song with her performance, taking me somewhere like what a person's feel when others mock you down , and sarah's version was LIVE yes LIVE while hailey's like a music video and theres a lot of fixing happens with the audio. Just saying. But thanks for making this VS thingy

Michael Angelo Depusoy
That's not live. That's recorded and edited

JK Velarde 5 days ago
Asia's Popstar Queen
SARAH GERONIMO

(his pick)

Romeo Estrella4 days ago
watched sarah's version of creep in the first night of her concert...That's way better than the video you reacted....I Love sarah and thank you for making reaction videos of Filipino singers....Thank you and more power to you...^_^

Worth ignoring

I couldn't agree more. I was with them until they mentioned the likelihood of post production editing on Haley's version of Creep. I can't imagine a singer out there that needs post production help less than Haley.

[john]

Haley's PMJ version of Creep has overtaken the "Homeless Mustard Sings "Creep" GREATEST Cover EVER - @OpieRadio" version to become the most popular cover of the song on Youtube. Since it was uploaded in 2009, Mustard's version has accumulated 21,858,957 views, while Haley's version has captured 21,893,153 views since April 2015.

Haley's version should reach the 22 million mark in a few days.