No, Haley would not have had to sing an octave lower. The point would have been to get the part sung by the guy to sound like a guy. As it is, there is virtually no distinction (regarding range) between the two of them. You are correct -- it works out OK, and ultimately I will have to get used to it, if I am to listen and enjoy it.
(11-05-2011, 09:59 AM)midnightblues Wrote: I wondered about them dropping the range a octive, but than Haley would have to go into a lower range,And she doesn't have that good of a lower regester eather.Thats not her strong point.But it all works out good.