(05-17-2013, 11:25 PM)Tusk Wrote: (05-17-2013, 11:12 PM)Swansteel Wrote: I'm glad season 10 had a resurgence in tour sales with mostly sold out shows.
Unfortunately, for S10, they got reduced pay AND had to do their own back up singing because AI didn't want to dole out money for extras on the tour. BUT That meant Haley got a chance to gain more on stage experience because she volunteered for more than any of the others. Built her stamina and allowed her to strengthen her stage presence. S11 benefitted greatly from S10's successful tour, mind you... much better compensation.
Let's face it, S10 was one of those confluences of events that resulted in something singularly unique. R&B was about the only genre that wasn't represented (some might argue that was what Stefano was trying to represent).
James brought something unique, metal tinged stadium rock, Casey goes without saying, and then there was Naima, Pia was the belter, and country was represented each with a 'girl and boy next door'.
Steven was there for Haley, and Randy played the Cartoony villain that everyone hissed at. It had Casey's dramatic save, Pia's shocking elimination and Haley's Epic Rise from the dust, Idol's Rocky Balboa, taking punches and still getting up not to mention her multiple Idol Moments....
S10 is the template of entertaining singing reality show competition
I really liked Season 10. I haven't been able to watch an entire idol show, for the last two seasons. There was just so much talent... of course tehre was Haley, but there were other 11 contestans that, with the exception of the 'country singers' top 2, all sang different genres and stuff. Pia had a great voice, Thia was very itneresting too. Paul! Pau lwas awesome! Naima was really unique. Not to mention CASEY! Jacob! Or James Durbin... I mean, Idol HAS to have a season like that again. I don't care if it's scripted, but make sure there is variety... I don't want to have five divas, or more than two coutnry singers, or more and more people just singing pop music.