RE: Idol ratings drop -- Did they shoot themselves in the foot in shooting down Haley?
Maybe personality isn't what I mean.
Perhaps "storyline" is better. Haley as the Rocky story line. James as overcoming disabilities and bringing entertainment. Lauren as the "perhaps too young" (and I agree completely with what you said there about them all being too young. But by ADD..I just mean..sometimes when giving a performance...you could see her eyes wander..Slezak explained it better. I love Lauren, not an insult..)
And maybe the "too young" was really the problem with idol in season 11. You had 3 really talented kids who just weren't ready yet.
|