Found this comment made about "You and I" at the time of the performance:
Quote:Haley got her hands on an unreleased Lady Gaga song...(her performance) gave us more of an Amy Winehouse vibe than Gaga.
http://fikklefame.com/haley-reinhart-the...dol-top-5/
Idol Chatter said this in their "Song Predictions For The Top 4: Leiber and Stoller Theme Night:"
Quote:“Is That All There Is?” by Peggy Lee
This song suits Haley’s vocal talents, she has that Adele/Amy Winehouse vibe, that jazzy soulful vibe. If she does this song, she will have another moment.