If Haley made it to the S9 top 3...?
...instead of S10 how do you think it would play out?
* Would Lee DeWyze split the Illinois vote with Haley or would she so overpower him he wouldn't even be in the top 4?
* Would Crystal Bowersox steal some of that midwest voting action?
* Would Casey James do better than Casey & James did in S10 and carry the country vote to the finale like Scotty & Lauren?
* Would Simon Cowell learn to love Haley or antagonize her like Randy?
* Would Kara DioGuardi show more support than J Lo did?
* Would there still be some misinterpreting of Haley's attitude one year younger?
* If the confetti fell on Haley in the finale with a song designed for her many vocal nuances and released during the Idol Tour would it have hit the Billboard top 20?
* Any other thoughts of how it would have worked for Haley in S9 rather than S10?
|