The Hollywood Reporter confirms Idol appearance by Haley

[john]

I've been traveling and it has been hard to keep up with Haley's week (although I was in LA the last couple days and probably within 15 miles of her when she performed today, LOL). I was able to tune into Idol tonight, but only after reading tweets, and posts here and on IDF. I became concerned and didn't quote know what to expect with the negativity I was encountering on the part of loyal Haliens. Would it be overproduced? with too much growling? with vocals drowned out by the music? with hair too big? and a WTF bird cage, etc.

The first thing I noticed was Courtney Leonard -- he reminded me of a security guard (maybe it was that blue lighting). John looked like a proper guitarist.

I thought Haley killed vocally and she looked stunning. I am just fine with the whole thing.

As far as the big production goes, I recall Haley talking about how she loved the star treatment that went along with the Idol experience. And I think she has been itching to do a fancy production on the big stage. She didn't get her street lamp on HOTRS, but got the big birdcage for Free. I would personally prefer a less produced performance -- think she connects better with the viewing audience with less production, but I have no problem with what she did. I thought the band sounded good and I want the music to be strong.

She has 90210 coming up and the promo machine will be kicking into a higher gear. Things are on track.