What's also up for comparison is the engineering on both tracks. I know Blake's is 10 years ago and I'm sure there've been many advances that an audio 'noob' like myself couldn't begin to understand, but it's quite striking what the same track in more experienced, talented hands can produce.
The sound and ambiance of the engineering in Haley's cover is, no doubt, superior than the one Idol put out for Blake.....
Haley waited to sign for this reason. In recent interviews she had hinted at having multiple offers on the table, I'd love to have heard the negotiations going on w/ Concord, what was promised, who suggested she work w/ esteemed engineers....did Haley know of them? Or did she tell Concord what she specifically wanted and Concord gave her suggestions of who they think could work for her.....
In other words, She chose wisely