Kimmell didn't invite contestants that weren't memorable. Each one (including Haley) were ones that stirred a lot of social media reaction and for that I think Haley can be proud to be in that group of the more recognizable Idols and controversial non-stars. The only real insult I felt was that Randy Jackasson was at the console at the end of the clip with his typical BS. This video may go viral and having Haley prominently displayed in the middle of the group with awesome body language reactions is the main focus
And to see the reappearance of the top 8 "Call Me" dress makes me proud to have this full page Haley-autographed poster with that dress on my Wall of Fame.