I took a different look at the data from Tusk's IDF survey. I tallied the number of times a song was ranked in the top 3 or the bottom 3 by the respondents (n=39). I used top and bottom 3 as a way to find the songs which elicited the strongest opinions.
Most likely to be in the top 3
26 (67%) Oh My
21 (54%) Undone
12 (31%) HTGR
09 (23%) NTYH
These are the songs people liked the best with the same three songs coming out on top as in Tusk's ranking. Wasted Tears (#4 in the Tusk ranking) comes in 8th with 6 votes tallied.
People that favored
Undone tended to like it a lot. It was ranked #1 by 13 people, whereas
Oh My was ranked #1 by 8 people despite the fact it was more likely to be in the top 3.
Oh My was most commonly ranked #2 by respondents (12 times).
Least likely to be in top 3
01 (2.6%) Free
02 (5.2%) Spiderweb
03 (7.7%) Walking on Heaven
These are the songs that were least likely to be favorites of the respondents.
Most likely to be in bottom 3
20 (51%) Spiderweb
18 (46%) Free
15 (38%) What You Don't Know
11 (28%) Wonderland
These are the songs that respondents liked the least.
Least likely to be in the top or bottom 3
08 (21%) Wasted Tears
13 (33%) Walking on Heaven
13 (33%) Now that You're Here
These are the songs that were unlikely to stir a strong opinion one way or the other.
If this is confusing try
this.