MJS put up a list of favorite performance from each season to mark the 10th anniversary of AI.
MJS Top AI performances from each of the last 10 seasons
As you might know, MJ is, at best, barely responsive to Haley to the point of almost dismissive (beyond posting news on Haley when it happens). She posted Casey's "Your Song" as her favorite from S10.
It did my Halien heart good to see so many of the comments list Haley and her songs as their best for S10. Haley by far had the most votes for best performance of that season (as well as posts wondering where Haley was on the list) Which had MJ conceding,
Quote:I knew that pick would be controversial (Her pick of Casey). lol. Actually, Season 10 was a weird season for me. I enjoyed it, but had no real favorites. Can't even name a favorite contestant. That's just how it shook out for me.
Come to think of it, I really liked Moanin' a lot too. I could have picked that one, easily.
And among the comments, we have someone that changed his entire opinion of Haley from one performance.
Quote:Casey as the season 10 surprised me. but listening to it reminded me how much i LOVED last seasons elton john episode. first lauren does candle in the wind, then casey and your song, and haley comes out and SHOCKS me with bennie and then jets (i hated her before) but these past two seasons have been pretty amazing. congrats nigel, watever ur doing is working!!!!!
