I REALLY like Majesty. I have a weakness for gap-toothed smiles. I LOVE A GAP TOOTH SMILE!! Her voice is good too haha.

On a side note, I'm so pissed right now!!!!!!!! We were just talking about the new season at work, and got on the subject of past contestants. A girl I worked with told about how she met Lauren Alaina and her mom after their season, and she asked if Haley was as big of a "B" as what she seemed like on the show, and that Lauren and her mom looked at each other and said it's better not to say anything negative if you can't say something positive. ANGER boiling up inside like it's 3 years ago!!! Then, another gal said she couldn't stand Haley that season for the same reason! I said, " People think that because of the way she stood up to Randy" and they said, "no, it's because she had a happy look on her face every time someone got eliminated." GAH don't talk to me for the rest of the day!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

To be fair to Lauren and her mother, it could have been simply that they were put off by the question, rather than what they thought of Haley, and the person who asked didn't get that. (I mean seriously, who asks that sort of question?) I mean, Lauren seemed like she adored Haley. And I remember Haley saying that Lauren's mother became someone she could talk to.

I agree with why would you ask that??? The gal who told the story is very young, maybe 23 - at the time she was interning at a radio station that was interviewing Lauren.

Sometimes people interpret what they hear into what they want to hear. The whole Haley hate thing has always been about interpretation

Don't forget, it was Lauren, not Scotty or James, who defended Haley after the Earth Song Randonkulosity

And it was Lauren who had the little impulsive squeaky "HALEY" scream when Haley made the top 3.

But, Scotty also stuck up for Haley. He was right next to Lauren, nodding his head, and when she was done he said he completely agreed with her.

Always interesting that the two youngest people involved in Idol that year were the ones to speak out. (While still in the competition. I think I remember Pia, Casey, Stefano and one of the girls who was eliminated before the top 12. Then of course there was the alumni demanding the judges give Haley an apology...)

Maybe you should show this pic of Haley that the Idol camera's didn't catch during Pia's elimination as they watched her journey on screen



Yup, she's definitely 'gleeful' that Pia got eliminated

(02-20-2014, 02:35 PM)NUG Wrote: A girl I worked with told about how she met Lauren Alaina and her mom after their season, and she asked if Haley was as big of a "B" as what she seemed like on the show, and that Lauren and her mom looked at each other and said it's better not to say anything negative if you can't say something positive. ANGER boiling up inside like it's 3 years ago!!! Then, another gal said she couldn't stand Haley that season for the same reason! I said, " People think that because of the way she stood up to Randy" and they said, "no, it's because she had a happy look on her face every time someone got eliminated." GAH don't talk to me for the rest of the day!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

It sounds a bit sketchy. Are you sure they weren't messing with you?

I could be wrong but it seems that all the "bitch" talk came from people watching the show on television. They often used screen caps or other nonsense as evidence.

One of the unfortunate effects of these singing contests is that people choose sides and then start trashing the competition. It's like fans of a sports team "hating" a rival team. People get stupid.

Woah..I got all the girls I wanted in the top 13 (Plus Kristen. I don't dislike her, but I find her boring.)

The guys...don't really care.

I think this is a really weak year.Last year may not have been the best but I did have Candice Glover to make me want to watch each week.This year I don't think its gonna happen.I thought that the five people chosen for the sing off was an excercize in futility.

Right! I was thinking "Why don't they just let Jena in, and have a top 11 instead.."

There's a lot of people (girls) who I like, but no one who I think is incredibly talented. Had to laugh when all five WGWGs got voted through, though.