I've watched most of this year's performances and have consistently enjoyed Skylar's songs. She is the most polished entertainer of this group and she may end up the most successful. Sorry to see her go.

Quote:James from last season was so much better than anyone from this season, he was such an accomplished musician and vocalist, it was a travesty to watch miss I’m free Haley reinhart beat him. He will have the last laugh though as he cleans up in album and concert sales

Comment by Tusk – May 3, 2012 09:56 PM PDT

It's probably obvious, but to make sure you know, someone's posting as me in the comments section @ TVLine, trumpeting James.

Probably our old pal "James" again....
Don't bother replying to him, just an FYI

(05-04-2012, 03:59 AM)Tusk Wrote:

Quote:James from last season was so much better than anyone from this season, he was such an accomplished musician and vocalist, it was a travesty to watch miss I’m free Haley reinhart beat him. He will have the last laugh though as he cleans up in album and concert sales

Comment by Tusk – May 3, 2012 09:56 PM PDT

It's probably obvious, but to make sure you know, someone's posting as me in the comments section @ TVLine, trumpeting James.

Probably our old pal "James" again.... Don't bother replying to him, just an FYI

Well, just how pathetic can one get!

.

It's not surprising someone who lacks any credibility of their own would attempt to appropriate that belonging to others.

---

Adam Lambert on Twitter:

"@JSanchezAI11 is a STAR. @jLedetAI11 sangs fo the blood. They wipe the floor with the other two. Its a SINGING competition. #keepinitreal"

---

Thought this comment Lovesyesha made on MJBB last night was amusing given how she used to rant against Haley.

Quote: Dear god America, give poor Hollie a break! The girl has been working her A** off every week and delivering some STELLAR performances only to be put in the bottom 3/2. Also, she has had to stand there for 3 consecutive weeks at the end of the show while someone else goes home. I am voting so hard for her next week! After all she's been through she deserves at LEAST a home visit.

(05-03-2012, 10:46 PM)Miguel Wrote:

Quote:American Idol Backstage Scoop: Did Jennifer Lopez Snub Tonight's Eliminated Contestant?

...Speaking of Jennifer, her lack of encouraging and comforting words with Skylar postshow seemed a little cold, and Skylar agreed it was a little weird.

"Jennifer didn't say much to me at the end," she spilled. "She just said, 'See you later.'

I've long thought that Jennifer is easily threatened by the women on Idol, because Jennifer's singing is not really even serviceable. It's her looks and moves that carry her. So while, it's revealing, it's not surprising that Jennifer didn't spend much time with Skylar.

---

[quote='john' pid='6702' dateline='1336109707']
I've watched most of this year's performances and have consistently enjoyed Skylar's songs. She is the most polished entertainer of this group and she may end up the most successful. Sorry to see her go.

This year's group of contestants has been quite the interesting mix. While I wasn't a great fan of Skylar (she has too much of a country, nasal twang for me), without a doubt she brings an energy to her performances, which was at times questionable, in view of the song she was singing, but usually great fun. And she performed an astonishing (at least, to me it was astonishing) rendition of "Where Do Broken Hearts Go."

She has a great future ahead of her though. Of that, I have no doubt.

So will Phil Phillips win, as I have feared since Top 13?

(05-04-2012, 08:44 AM)My Alter Ego Wrote: So will Phil Phillips win, as I have feared since Top 13?

As of Thursday night he still had the biggest fan base, but that could change as some of these other contestants with huge fan bases get knocked off now and jump on other bandwagons.

I was sorry to see Skylar go, as PP was easily the least good on Wednesday night and should have been the one made to go.

(05-04-2012, 04:56 AM)My Alter Ego Wrote: Well, just how pathetic can one get!

It's really quite odd behaviour, really. I already had to change my log in months ago to "Q" because for some reason, I attract these posters that are adamant on .....'taking me on' is the best way I can describe it.

I left as "Tusk" because Haleyloonies was shifting to me as a focus instead of Haley, for some reason, and I go there to discuss Haley, not justify or debate anything. Leaving removed the target for a spell, and the discussion went back to Haley.

It's probably because I post so much that I draw the attention and become a target for whatever these people hate about Haley or her fans.
(It happened to Hiphogamer @ IDF when someone assumed his twitter name and started saying nasty things about Haley....I saw her acct before she took it down, she couldn't have been older than 14, slightly over weight and seemed, from her videos, to have pretty low self esteem. It seemed to explain, a little, what kind of personallity would engage in this kind of thing.)

I've run into a lull for posting, so the album can't come soon enough for more fun things to post about....

Hell Tusk, the album can't come soon enough so that we'll get another 9 tracks of new Haley music to enjoy...

(05-04-2012, 08:44 AM)My Alter Ego Wrote: So will Phil Phillips win, as I have feared since Top 13?

(05-04-2012, 01:20 PM)John Brown Wrote: As of Thursday night he still had the biggest fan base, but that could change as some of these other contestants with huge fan bases get knocked off now and jump on other bandwagons.

I was sorry to see Skylar go, as PP was easily the least good on Wednesday night and should have been the one made to go.

That assumes that viewers that had prior loyalties will switch their votes to the remaining contestants. That may not be the case.

(05-04-2012, 01:57 PM)Tusk Wrote: It's probably because I post so much that I draw the attention and become a target...It happened to Hiphogamer @ IDF when someone assumed his twitter name

It's the venue more than you. I started HaleyFans because there was a need for a site that was actively moderated and had the tools required to police troublemakers.