TV Guide - Who's the Best American Idol Ever?

[Himm2]

http://www.tvguide.com/special/winter-pr...eid=celebs

Haliens unite in pushing Haley up the list! Unfortunately you have to pick 5 Idols before you can vote and your 5th pick is of equal weight to your 1st pick which lessens Haley's chance of moving up unless you pick the bottom 4 with her. She's in the dead center of best/popularity rankings. These are the current vote totals:

Most Popular Picks
1211 votes 11% Kelly Clarkson, Season 1
1032 votes 9% Carrie Underwood, Season 4
728 votes 7% Chris Daughtry, Season 5
537 votes 5% David Cook, Season 7
534 votes 5% Clay Aiken, Season 2
482 votes 4% Jennifer Hudson, Season 3
481 votes 4% Adam Lambert, Season 8
421 votes 4% Phillip Phillips, Season 11
379 votes 3% David Archuleta, Season 7
370 votes 3% Kris Allen, Season 8
357 votes 3% Scotty McCreery, Season 10
356 votes 3% Kellie Pickler, Season 5
317 votes 3% Jordin Sparks, Season 6
306 votes 3% Katharine McPhee, Season 5
304 votes 3% Crystal Bowersox, Season 9
272 votes 2% Haley Reinhart, Season 10
262 votes 2% Bo Bice, Season 4
259 votes 2% Melinda Doolittle, Season 6
244 votes 2% Ruben Studdard, Season 2
232 votes 2% Elliott Yamin, Season 5
230 votes 2% Colton Dixon, Season 11
200 votes 2% Lee DeWyze, Season 9
197 votes 2% Tamyra Gray, Season 1
195 votes 2% Jessica Sanchez, Season 11
193 votes 2% Pia Toscano, Season 10
187 votes 2% Lauren Alaina, Season 10
186 votes 2% Taylor Hicks, Season 5
166 votes 1% Fantasia Barrino, Season 3
161 votes 1% Justin Guarini, Season 1
159 votes 1% LaToya London, Season 3
142 votes 1% Kimberly Locke, Season 2

[reinhart_arm]

Is tvguide.com a "big" site?

[midnightblues]

Anything to suport the Hales count me in.

[Miguel]

Is tvguide.com a "big" site?

TV Guide has been around for sixty years and enjoys widespread name recognition. But they have been hurt by cable television and the Internet.

The sheer amount and diversity of cable TV programming made it hard for TV Guide to provide listings of the extensive array of programming that came directly over the cable system. TV Guide also could not match the ability of the cable box to store personalized listings. TV Guide's circulation went from almost 20 million in 1970 to less than three million in 2007.

...On October 13, 2008, Macrovision sold the money-losing magazine to equity fund OpenGate Capital for $1. As part of the sale, however, the companion website was retained by Macrovision (who then sold it to One Equity Partners), with all editorial connections between the magazine and website severed, including the end of Matt Roush's presence on TVGuide.com. The editorial content of the magazine was launched on a new site, TVGuideMagazine.com, which didn't feature TV Guide's listings in any form. However, TVGuidemagazine.com was shut down on June 1, 2010 and TV Guide Magazine and TVGuide.com entered into a deal to restore content from the magazine to the TVGuide.com website, which Lionsgate bought along with the TV Guide Network in January 2009.

[john]

Not TV Guide, but Yahoo Entertainment. I was just trying to find a place this might fit.

Ranking 10 Seasons of American Idol Girls
61 Fabulous Ladies! Who Will Make the Top 10?

http://voices.yahoo.com/ranking-10-seaso...tml?cat=33

Haley ties.
Lauren comes in 43rd.