Haley appearing on Idol - Feb 18 2016

[dswim2]

A duet with her and Trent would be epic. Still holding out for that

[dswim2]

Interesting information on the wiki. It's probably not accurate, but it says she's doing a duet with Trent--"Bennie and the Jets"--and Lee--"Earth Song".
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American...season_15)

[john]

Interesting information on the wiki. It's probably not accurate, but it says she's doing a duet with Trent--"Bennie and the Jets"--and Lee--"Earth Song".
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American...season_15)

Hard to know. I wonder if people affiliated with the show are behind some of the bogus information and confusion. The wiki page only has a few of the pairings and they happen to include Haley's. That would be funny if she did Earth Song. The duets get an extra 30 seconds to do the build.

[Miguel]

Not likely, but it would be funny. I expect an amusing reaction online from a few people who were not fans of Haley and let the world know it. I think the studio audience will greet her enthusiastically as it appears (at least in one pic) to be comprised primarily of young women who were pre-teen girls when Haley first appeared on Idol. Many of them now probably identify her with CHFIL.

[Tusk]

I've been reading some of the comments on TVLine, it's laughable sometimes someone would just insert an off topic "I can't stand Haley's attitude" into the discussion out of the blue....

You have to think there's more to it than not 'liking' Haley when you carry that kind of 'venom' towards someone you don't even know for 5 years.... it's just laughable

[dswim2]

Now it says she's singing can't help falling in love instead of earth song...lol

[Himm2]

Hey Buzz!?! Did you change the Wiki listing for Dalton Rappatoni? haha:

Order Contestant Song Order Duet partner Duet Song Result
1 Jenn Blosil " Sorry" TBD Haley Reinhart TBD TBD
2 Amelia Eisenhauer "TBD" TBD Haley Reinhart TBD TBD
3 Trent Harmon "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
4 Lee Jean "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
5 C.J. Johnson "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
6 Adam Lasher "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
7 Tristan McIntosh "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
8 Dalton Rappatoni "Rebel Yell" TBD TBD TBD TBD
9 Olivia Rox "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
10 Manny Torres "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
11 Kory Wheeler "TBD" TBD TBD TBD TBD
12 Shelbie Z "TBD" TBD Kellie Pickler TBD TBD

[Miguel]

Some comments on the Atlanta Journal Constitution's recap of the show (which is still providing in-depth coverage):

OK now I get to reprise my biggest beef with American Idol. How in the world did Scotty beat out Lauren Alaina???

And Haley Reinhardt came in 3rd??? No friggin' way!!!

---

Person A:

It kind of shows the flaws of this format. It's great to see the former Idol's, but they will probably always blow away the current contestants.

Heck, next week with Haley Reinhart? Whoever the contestants are next week don't stand a chance.

Person B's response:

Haley will flatten anyone she sings with and if she doesn't there's a good chance we're looking at this season's winner.

Person C's response:

Heard Elton John singing Bennie and the Jets at Publix yesterday and my initial reaction was, dang, wish it was the Haley version.

[Himm2]

Contrary to popular belief:



That leaves either Kory Wheeler, Manny Torres, C.J. Johnson, or Lee jean as Haley's other duet.

[InItToWinIt]

Hmmm...Himm. So Adam and Kory? That's not what I wanted to hear. I'm guessing that's CHFIL she's singing w/Adam.